Testing Times for Teachers as Gove Speech Praises Tests

michael gove speech IAA 150x150 speeches

Michael Gove, Education Secretary, speaking at conference

There aren’t many heavyweight politicians today who can begin a speech with the words:

Stanley Baldwin, the Conservative Prime Minister who won more elections than any other in history, was once asked what was the most significant thing that he had ever learned about politics…

But it’s the sort of beginning to a speech that we can expect from the scholarly Michael Gove, the Education Secretary.

In a speech to the Independent Academies Association he used a story about Stanley Baldwin to introduce the subjects of knowledge and learning…and the lengths that some people go to disguise their learning.

His speech contained some fine repetition of the phrase:

Bias against knowledge

But this wasn’t just sanctimonious stuff. There was humour:

This bias against knowledge manifested itself most recently when the otherwise saintly inventor Sir James Dyson had a crack at people who want to go to university to learn French lesbian poetry rather than applying themselves to matters technical.

The speech again showed that Mr Gove has a real fondness for words:

It’s like professing a love of cookery – hymning the beauty of perfectly baked souffles or rhapsodising over richly unguent risottos – and then saying the most important thing about food is checking the calorie count in every mouthful. Isn’t an obsession with measurement the enemy of enjoyment, the desire to assess and examine the death of learning for its own sake?

Who else around the Cabinet table would attempt that? He’s also a politician whose speeches brim with sentences not clauses devoid of verbs. But even Mr Gove aspires to a good soundbite in his speeches:

Exams matter because motivation matters.

His speech included some good word-pairing…a favoured technique of exquisite orators such as Ronald Reagan:

Humans are hard-wired to seek out challenges. And our self-belief grows as we clear challenges we once thought beyond us.

And on the subject of American Presidents, how about Michael Gove’s borrowing of a phrase from President George W. Bush? It can’t be that often that someone borrows from a George Dubya speech:

With external testing there is no opportunity for such bias – the soft bigotry of low expectations – and tests show ethnic minority students performing better.

So external tests are not only a way of leveling the playing field for children of all backgrounds they are a solvent of prejudice.

George W. Bush introduced “the soft bigotry of low expectations” in a position taker he made in a speech in 2000:

Some say it is unfair to hold disadvantaged children to rigorous standards. I say it is discrimination to require anything less–the soft bigotry of low expectations.

In terms of structure the Education Secretary had seven reasons to support exams. An odd choice of number. Far from memorable. He didn’t make much attempt to keep referring to the number of reasons…at times it was certainly hard to establish which reason he was discussing.

He kept his seventh and final reason for his conclusion:

And that brings me to my final argument. Schools that take tests seriously take students seriously. Schools that want exam success want their students to succeed. And schools that pursue academic excellence give their students the potential to beat the world.

And that was that, a convincing end to another fine speech from Mr Gove.


 

email

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

CommentLuv badge

Back to top ▴