We’re All in This Together: Cameron’s Scotland Union Speech

By Andrew Ivey | Speeches

Feb 17

With the visually rich backdrop of Edinburgh castle the Prime Minister, David Cameron, made an equally rich state of the union speech yesterday preceding talks on a Scottish independence referendum.

His speech drew immediate attention to his leadership of a minority political party in Scotland–making light of it. That was perhaps the only strategy available.

Speaking from notes his body position never seemed settled. He had to look to both extremes of left and right to clearly view his audience. That might be a metaphor for the political views in his audience, but it’s not intentional.

As a speaker he’s also got himself into the habit of bending his knees and crouching into his microphone as he emphasises key points in his speeches. This habit is slightly unsettling and could even be distracting. Again there’s no metaphor intended with a Tory Prime Minister on bended knee in Scotland, pleasing as it might be to some.

But body movement apart, there’s also a marked difference with this speech. One senses that there’s a new speech writing team in Downing Street.

Descriptive phrases featured very prominently in this speech…sounding very similar to the speech style of the Education Minister, the Aberdonian Michael Gove.

For example we heard:

The air in Scotland hangs heavy with history. Edinburgh’s cityscape is studded with monuments to memories.


And while the hauntingly empty acres of the Highlands stand in mute memorial to the injustices visited on the victims of the clearances, Glasgow’s magnificent architecture and art galleries remind us of the mercantile greatness of the Empire’s second city.

Symbolism, like the castle backdrop, was everywhere in this speech. We had military symbolism:

That’s not because I want to dragoon Scotland into an arrangement which is in my interests. Or, frankly, my party’s interests.


That is partly because its history is populated so thickly with great men and women who we might want to conscript for our contemporary battles.


From Waterloo to the Second World War our servicemen and women have fought and won together. The liberation of Europe was a battle fought to the skirl of the pipes as Lord Lovat’s Highlanders were among the first ashore on D-Day in the battle to defeat Hitler.

But with the symbolism to one side, this speech spoke clearly with one objective, or one message as the Prime minister noted:

So – I come here today with one simple message: I hope and wish that Scotland will vote to remain part of the UK.

A rich language was certainly the highlight of this speech. But rhetorical flourishes, favoured by the Prime Minister, featured prominently. There was some excellent alliteration with:

A United Kingdom which is not monoglot, monochrome and minimalist but multi-national, multi-cultural and modern in every way. Our United Kingdom.

By way of peroration his speech noted:

If anything’s worth fighting for that surely is; which is why I’m ready for the fight for our country’s life.

More martial symbolism in a re-capitulation of the main point for this speech.


About the Author

The Principal Trainer at training business Time to Market. Based in Oxford, I run presentation and public speaking training courses, coaching sessions and seminars throughout the UK. Andrew Ivey on Google+

(1) comment

Add Your Reply